Today we mark the 85th anniversary of the birth of one of the great voices of our time – Dusty Springfield. Or to her parents, Mary Catherine O’Brien, Britain’s finest Blue-eyed soul singing woman, and to many, one of that land’s greatest singers ever. Period.
We’ve looked at Dusty’s career a bit before, so today let’s just focus on one of her best, and most iconic tunes – “Son of a Preacher Man.” Although she was born to a dad who was a tax accountant, one would have believed listening to the single she was in fact infatuated by a preacher’s son. Turns out she probably would have been more infatuated with the daughter of a preacher man, a fact which would not have helped her career whatsover in the 1960s.
“Son of a Preacher Man” was a song written by the duo of John Hurley and Ronnie Wilkins, who’d actually written it for Aretha Franklin. Franklin did record it, but seemed unimpressed and didn’t release it for a long time, so when Dusty signed to Atlantic Records for North America and went to Memphis to record it was offered to her. She went to Chip Moman’s American Sound studio there, and they brought in some of the best Tennessee session players to back her on what would become Dusty in Memphis. Among them, guitarist Reggie Young who’d played on hits like “The Letter” for the Boxtops and the iconic “Sweet Caroline” of Neil Diamond’s.
The song was put out as the first single off it, and while now a classic, it did … half-decently at the time. It got to #9 at home for her, #10 in the U.S. and #11 in Canada. The album itself at the time flopped in a huge way. It only cracked the charts in the States… but there it got to only #99. Her career was actually on a downturn then; she’d been named the NME‘s Female Singer of the Year in 1965, ’66 and ’67. this would help her win it again in 1969, when “Son of a Preacher Man” ran up the charts. She’d actually had a number of bigger hits at the time, like “You Don’t Have to Say You Love Me” (a #1 in the UK and #4 in the U.S.) but eventually it would go on to be double-platinum in Britain and her biggest-seller. Likewise, the album itself grew in reputation over the years – usually perpetually-negative Robert Christgau calls it “the all-time rock era torch record” for example and it’s on many lists of the Best of the ’60s.
Curiously, Dusty wasn’t enthralled with her own take on it and allegedly wanted the producers to let her re-record it. Good thing they declined? Likewise, later when she heard Franklin’s version she was noted as saying “Goddamnit, that’s the way I should have done it!” Most disagree.
Rolling Stone, who put Aretha as having the best single of all-time in their reckoning and rate her the best singer ever, put Dusty’s version at #168 of greatest recordings of all-time… way ahead of Franklin’s. Someone else who was doubtless happy Dusty did the song the way only she could was Elton John. When Dusty was inducted into the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame in’99, just before she passed away and just before what would have been her 60th birthday, Elton inducted her and said she was the first person he’d ever joined a fan club of, he had posters of her on his walls when he was young and he considered her perhaps “the greatest White Singer” of our time.
Dusty’s career went downhill quickly, unfortunately, after her Memphis album, until she was asked to join the Pet Shop Boys on their hit “What Have I Done To deserve This?” in 1987, a top 5 hit almost worldwide.